top of page
Search

Dealer of fake Morrisseau art facing lengthy prison sentence

4 minutes ago
3 min read

Crown asking for 'upper range of five to eight years' behind bars, while defence has countered with house arrest; judge expected to impose sentence Feb. 3


Journalist: Peter Robinson (Barrie News)


JEFF COWAN leaves the Barrie courthouse in this file photo. (Peter Robinson BarrieToday)
JEFF COWAN leaves the Barrie courthouse in this file photo. (Peter Robinson BarrieToday)

Jeff Cowan is facing up to eight years in prison as the case against the lone person yet to be sentenced stemming from the mass selling of fraudulent Norval Morrisseau art winds down.


Superior Court Laura Bird is expected to impose a sentence Feb. 3 in Barrie.


Cowan, 50, appeared by video as his lawyer Nathan Gorham countered the Crown by requesting a conditional sentence – house arrest – which by law must be two years or less.


By contrast, Crown attorney Joseph Heller told Bird that Cowan, convicted of four fraud and related counts by a Barrie jury last year, should be sentenced in the “upper range of five to eight years.”


Heller told court that Cowan has been connected to at least 800 dodgy works over 14 years, much of it sold for his own financial benefit.


The Crown said Cowan contributed to flooding the marketplace, devaluing legitimate Morrisseau art in the process, all while committing serious acts of cultural appropriation.


“The harm was devastating and far-reaching,” said Heller, who also cited the “humiliation” that duped buyers felt when they discovered they'd been hoodwinked into buying mimicked Morrisseaus.


Gorham positioned his client’s actions as a small part of a much bigger problem that includes members of Morrisseau’s family and his estate being complicit in the sale of fake and purported works by the famed painter.


“The question is, what is authentic and what is not?” Gorham told the court. “…And how was Jeff Cowan to know?”


Gorham also stressed that his client never produced any fraudulent art himself.

Cowan declined an opportunity to the address the court. He represented himself at trial, but hired Gorham for sentencing.


That phase soon became bogged down as Gorham sought to examine various issues to mitigate his client’s sentence. Gorham’s most extensive queries centred on the role that those close to Morrisseau and his estate may have had in the sale of fraud.


Morrisseau expert John Zemanovich was called to testify and spent multiple days on the stand sprinkled over the summer and fall.


Representatives of the Morrisseau estate refused to participate, as they had done in the sentencing hearing of two previous defendants, David Paul Bremmner and Jim White, both of whom were sentenced to periods of house arrest.


The case has attracted attention due to Morrisseau’s acclaim and the various hot-button issues it entailed. There was an indeterminate amount of victims, spread far and wide. One was Kevin Hearn of the Barenaked Ladies.


To that end, it was interesting that when Heller was referencing certain elements of case law to support his position, two incidents that had previously attracted widespread media attention were cited by the Crown.


The first was the case of Garth Drabinsky, the former Livent theatre impresario who was convicted of fraud in 2009 and sentenced to seven years in prison, later reduced to five on appeal.


The second was the infamous theft of the “roaring lion” portrait of Winston Churchill that was taken from the Chateau Laurier hotel in Ottawa. Jeffrey Wood was convicted of stealing the Yousef Karsh image, which was replaced with a fake. Wood was sentenced to two years, but he has since been granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada.


The authentic Churchill portrait was located in Italy and returned to Canada. It is now back hanging at the Chateau Laurier.


The victims in the Morrisseau fraud will see no such happy ending.

 
 
bottom of page